debris4spike: (Reading.)
[personal profile] debris4spike
Dad had no internet link this weekend which was slightly annoying, however it did mean that I didn't get myself side-tracked.

In my spare time I have done a lot of reading.

I am one of the judges on one of the competitions that is running at present.  This is not the first time I have done it.  When I originally offered it was because I read a lot of Spuffy I thought that it would be re-reading some of the stuff I had already read.  I soon discovered this wasn't quite what I had to do!  This set of reading involves 2 different catagories and includes - 

1)  W.I.P.'s ... And most of you know I don't like reading those!

2)  Cross-overs ... one of which in a setting that I would not have chosen to read.

3)  Human

4)  Stories from 3 on my f-list!!!!!

5)  Stories I had already read and (fortunately) loved, as I know have to re-read to note upon the specific points of the set category.

6)  Stories from a web site I never even look at!

So I have 16 Spuffy stories to read ... on the way back here, from Mum and Dad's, it made me start to think about what I like about Spuffy stories.  For those writers that I am writing, let me assure you that this is not what I am "marking" ... these have just stimulated my brain ... scary thought! 


So - What do I like about Spuffy stories.

This is really going to be a bit of a ramble and in no particular order ... just as I think about it.

I do like a happy ending!  However I do also enjoy canon - so read Season 5 with Buffy's death, as well as Season 7 and Spike's death.  Still I suppose it was this that got me into LJ!  I had written a post-BTVS story and needed a beta - and thus found LJ.

I enjoy good plot twists - maybe that is why I love the time travel fics and baby fics.

I do like some of the ficlets and an occasional PWP - but basically I prefer stories where their feelings are explored.  In doing so I have read some amazing epics, but also some stunning drabbles.

Further to that, although I like a happy ending, I don't like it when the plot twists too quickly for no real reason.  I can accept unusual turns, but I like to have a reason for the 2 of them to be together.  

They have a lot of inherant problems and it is good when at least some of these get explored.  There are some great loop-holes that have allowed authors to get round these problems.  However, I suppose because I love the consept of Eternal Love - I prefer tales where Buffy ends up immortal with a claim or as the slayer; rather than Spike having the Shanshu.

It's the same with The Scoobies and Joyce.  I don't mind how the author plays their characters, but if there is to be support and hepl for them then it has to be for a reason, or after a series of events that has covered some time!

What I like to see in Spike

I like to see him strong - mentally and physically.  I love some of the fics where his age is used for him to have knowledge of languages etc.

Emotionally I love seeing that he is constant in his love.  I like him to be there for Dru and Buffy (depending on the timing) ... and can cope with seeing him have his heart ripped apart by either of them - it just makes me want to hug him more!

I love some of the stories where his background is explored - and have read some great plot twists that have him involved with, or related to ,various people when he was human!

I like Spike both with and without his soul.  I fell in love with him in season 7 as this was the first series I watched - but seeing his constant love is something, in this context, that is the important factor for me.

Buffy, on the other hand is easier for me to read.  I like her character as it developes over the 7 years.  She is strong - but her heart is too well protected.  One of the things that I find hardest to read is if she has a sudden change in heart.  She has a lot of heartache that she needs to both work through - and eventually to share with Spike .... perfect Spuffy moment for me!

And, no thoughts on Spuffy can be complete without a mention of Angel and to a certain degree, Dru.  Both of them deserve to be mentioned in stories - but I don't mind which way the plot takes them ... providing Spike and Buffy end up together, that is the important thing!


As well as reading the Spuffy stories I have also helped my Dad by doing a final proof-read of the book that he has finished recently.  It is brilliant that my Dad, at 83, has just completed a book about the prophesies within the book of "The Revelation" in The Bible. 

Date: 2008-02-24 11:02 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] laura-writes.livejournal.com
I don't really read fan fiction unless it's written by my best friend, but I am sitting on a panel to judge new books for an online magazine. These books are published (sometimes self-published) and are of the genre type, so fantasy, mystery, horror, humor, etc. It's a bit daunting really. I had 20 books to weed through, to come up with a top three.

Good luck on your judging!

Date: 2008-02-24 11:28 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] oldgreymare.livejournal.com
Wow it sounds like a big task you have taken on there.
I dont read fan fiction - I tried but just couldn't really get in to it at all.

But I do agree with :- "I like to see him strong - mentally and physically.""Emotionally I love seeing that he is constant in his love.""I like Spike both with and without his soul."

Not a Spuffy follower so I would not want to see Spike and Buffy together. *Sorry* In fact I loved the conection he had with Dru and much preferred that storyline. Or in my world I got Spike *g*

Date: 2008-02-25 04:32 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] classicanne01.livejournal.com
I do not envy your job in reading through and judging other people's work. That's tough stuff.

Kudos to you dad too! That's amazing!

Date: 2008-02-25 08:58 pm (UTC)
cordykitten: (OTP)
From: [personal profile] cordykitten
I like my happy ending too; I just don't need to read a story that ends bad. Loss of time, most of the time.

Date: 2008-03-10 08:57 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] winsomeone.livejournal.com
This was an interesting post. I have my own mental wish list of what I like in my Spuffy, too. I'm sure most fanfic readers are the same, we all have things we like and dislike. It was interesting to see someone else's preferences.
I won't read WIP's at all and I really don't enjoy reading fic one chapter at a time over a period of weeks or even months, even with the promise of completion. I become bored with the plot. I want to read it just like a real novel or short story- when it's convenient for me and as much as I have time for at that moment, not every other Wed or whatever.

Kudos for judging all those stories. I hope you discovered either a new writer or a new story that you really enjoyed -even if it is a WIP- that would make it all worthwhile. :-)

Congrats to your dad!!! That's absolutely wonderful.

January 2026

S M T W T F S
     1 23
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Most Popular Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags